What does Luke 7:32 mean?
Explanation
The verse in question, Luke 7:32, uses a simile to draw a comparison between the generation Jesus was addressing and children in a marketplace who are discontented and disengaged, regardless of what is done to try and please them.
In this analogy, Jesus describes the people as unable to be satisfied – neither responding to joyful music nor to sorrowful lament.
The deeper meaning implies that Jesus’ contemporaries were indifferent or unresponsive to God's message no matter how it was presented.
They were like children who complain to their playmates that no matter what they do – whether it is a game of wedding (piping and dancing) or a game of funeral (mourning and weeping) – their peers are not participating or reciprocating.
Top Rated Luke Books
Historical Context
This saying of Jesus is situated in the context of the rejection of both John the Baptist and Jesus by the people.
This verse comes shortly after Jesus has spoken about John the Baptist's ministry. John had a very ascetic lifestyle, which led some to say he had a demon; whereas Jesus had a more open approach to social engagements and was accused of being a glutton and a drunkard (Luke 7:33-34).
This verse reflects the cultural practice of children playing common social events of the time, like weddings and funerals, in public spaces such as marketplaces.
Theological Insights
Theologically, the verse has been interpreted as a critique of human fickleness and the tendency to reject messengers of God who do not fit preconceived expectations.
Jesus uses this analogy to imply that the people's unwillingness to listen to either John the Baptist’s or his own message reveals a deeper spiritual blindness.
Moreover, from a Christian theological viewpoint, it points to the theme of accountability; the generation is held accountable for their response to God's diverse ways of revelation.
Practical Applications
This verse can be practically applied as a call to self-examination about how one responds to God's messages and those who deliver them.
It teaches humility and openness to different forms of divine communication, serving as a reminder not to reject the truth just because it doesn't conform to our expectations or come to us in a form we find agreeable.
Cross-References
- Matthew 11:16-17, "But whereunto shall I liken this generation? It is like unto children sitting in the marketplaces, and calling unto their fellows, And saying, We have piped unto you, and ye have not danced; we have mourned unto you, and ye have not lamented."
- Ecclesiastes 7:5, "It is better to hear the rebuke of the wise, than for a man to hear the song of fools."
- Matthew 13:13, "Therefore I speak to them in parables: because they seeing see not; and hearing they hear not, neither do they understand."
Language Study
In the original Greek text, the words used are important to drawing out the full meaning of the verse:
- "Children" (παιδίοις, paidiois) conveys not just young humans but implies immaturity or a lack of understanding.
- "Marketplace" (ἀγορᾷ, agorā) is a central gathering place in ancient cities, the hub of social and commercial life.
- "Piped" (ηὐλήσαμεν, eulēsamen) refers to playing a flute-like instrument, associated with festivities and celebrations, like weddings.
- "Mourned" (ἐθρηνήσαμεν, ethrēnēsamen) indicates deep lamentation or expression of sorrow, such as at funerals.
Cultural and Religious Comparisons
This verse is unique to the Christian context in which it is used, but the broader idea of leaders or prophetic figures being rejected by their own people is found in various cultures.
For example, in Greek mythology, Cassandra was given the gift of prophecy by Apollo but was cursed to never be believed.
In many religious traditions, divine messengers are often met with hostility or indifference.
Scientific Perspectives
While this verse does not directly intersect with scientific study, concepts of human psychology and behavior described by this scripture have been explored in various scientific fields.
The notion of cognitive dissonance, where individuals resist or reject new information because it conflicts with their existing beliefs, could be seen as relevant to the behaviors that Jesus is criticizing.
Commentaries
- Matthew Henry's Commentary emphasizes the stubbornness of the people, comparing them as unresponsive to John the Baptist's austerity and Jesus' more social approach.
- Benson Commentary suggests that the image illustrates the capriciousness and inconsistency of the people, who were not satisfied with either the strictness of John or the liberality of Jesus.
- The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges highlights that Jesus describes the generation as playing at the games of weddings and funerals, but not with appropriate emotion or response, illustrating spiritual insensitivity.
- The Pulpit Commentary discusses the comparison to children as signifying Jesus' disappointment at the unreasonableness and perversity of the public opinion of his day, which found fault with every approach.