What does Mark 15:34 mean?
Explanation
Mark 15:34 recounts a moment of profound anguish and human emotion from Jesus as he hung on the cross.
In this verse, Jesus cries out to God in Aramaic, "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?" which is translated as "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" This expression illustrates a sense of abandonment and despair, indicating that Jesus is experiencing a deep sense of separation from God the Father during his crucifixion.
This cry is a direct quotation from Psalm 22:1, thus linking Jesus' suffering to the experiences and prophetic writings of King David.
The deeper meaning behind this expression has been the subject of much theological debate.
Some interpret it as Jesus bearing the full weight of humanity's sins, feeling isolated from the divine presence due to the sin he carried on behalf of humanity.
Others suggest it reflects Jesus' full identification with human suffering, emphasizing his role as a compassionate and empathetic savior who understands the depth of human despair.
Top Rated Mark Books
Historical Context
The Gospel of Mark, traditionally attributed to John Mark, is one of the four canonical gospels and is considered by most scholars to be the earliest gospel written, dated around 60-75 AD.
Written in a historical period of early Christian persecution and struggle, this verse reflects the community's need to understand the suffering and death of their Messiah.
The context of Roman crucifixion, a punishment reserved for slaves and the most heinous criminals, provides a stark backdrop for the theological emphasis on Jesus' passion and sacrifice.
Theological Insights
Theologically, this verse has been a cornerstone for various interpretations of Jesus' crucifixion.
From a classic Christian viewpoint, it underscores the doctrine of atonement, signifying Jesus' suffering as a redemptive act necessary for the salvation of humanity.
Some theologians suggest that Jesus' sense of abandonment was real and that in that moment, he experienced a genuine separation from God due to the sin he bore.
In contrast, others propose that Jesus remained united with God the Father throughout his passion and that his cry was a deliberate fulfillment of prophecy, not a literal expression of divine abandonment.
This perspective maintains that Jesus' knowledge of his divine mission never wavered, even during his moment of distress.
Practical Applications
The practical applications of Mark 15:34 involve the recognition that feelings of abandonment and despair can be a part of the human experience, even for those who have faith.
It teaches that in moments of great suffering, it is not uncommon to feel forsaken, and yet, this does not mean one is actually abandoned by God.
Furthermore, Jesus' cry can be seen as an invitation to bring one's own feelings of desolation to God in prayer, trusting in God's ultimate faithfulness and love.
Cross-References
- Psalm 22:1 - "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? why art thou so far from helping me, and from the words of my roaring?"
- Matthew 27:46 - "And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is to say, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?"
Language Study
The key words in the original language are "Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani" which is an Aramaic phrase.
The term "Eloi" (אלי) translates as "my God", and the question "lama sabachthani" (למה שבקתני) means "why have you forsaken me". The use of Aramaic is significant because it was the common language spoken by the Jewish people in Jesus' time.
The phrase encapsulates Jesus' intense emotional and spiritual suffering, and the use of "my God" indicates a personal relationship with the divine.
Cultural and Religious Comparisons
This moment in Christian narrative can be compared to various instances in other religious traditions where a figure experiences a form of divine abandonment or a test of faith.
For instance, in Hindu mythology, the god Rama suffers separation from his beloved wife Sita, which can similarly be seen as a trial of his virtue and commitment.
Comparative mythology often finds themes of suffering, abandonment, and ultimate redemption as universal.
Scientific Perspectives
From a modern scientific perspective, the experience of feeling forsaken, particularly in times of stress or trauma, can be understood within the framework of human psychology.
Research on the psychological impact of pain and suffering can provide insights into the effects of extreme stress on the perception of social and spiritual connectedness.
However, the scientific approach does not typically address or validate the spiritual and theological dimensions of these experiences.
Commentaries
Biblical scholars and theologians have offered various interpretations of Mark 15:34.
Some, like theologian Frederick Bruner, emphasize Jesus' identification with humanity in our deepest cries of abandonment.
Others, such as John Calvin, viewed this moment as symbolic of the spiritual agony Jesus endured as he bore the penalty of human sin.
Meanwhile, biblical scholar R.
T.
France has suggested that this cry is a deliberate use of Psalm 22, which, though starting with despair, ends with a note of triumph and vindication, thus pointing to the deeper understanding of Jesus' suffering as ultimately leading to glory.