What does John 11:46 mean?
Explanation
John 11:46 refers to a pivotal moment in the Gospel of John where certain individuals, upon witnessing the miraculous resurrection of Lazarus by Jesus, took the news to the Pharisees.
The verse marks a turning point in the narrative because it sets in motion the events leading up to the decision of the Pharisaic council to plot the death of Jesus.
This verse emphasizes the division of opinion among those who witnessed Jesus’ miracles: while some believed in Him, others went to the religious authorities, which could be seen as an act of betrayal or concern depending on interpretation.
The deeper meaning could reflect how miraculous signs can polarize people, prompting different reactions based on their beliefs and allegiances.
Top Rated John Books
Historical Context
During the time of Jesus, the Pharisees were a prominent Jewish sect known for their strict adherence to the Torah and the oral traditions.
The news of Jesus raising Lazarus from the dead presented a theological and political challenge to the Phariseal authority.
In the historical context of Roman-occupied Judea, any movement that could attract a substantial following posed a risk of uprising that the Pharisees feared could threaten the uneasy peace with Roman authorities and their own societal position.
Theological Insights
From a theological perspective, different traditions have interpreted this verse in various ways:
- Traditional Christian interpretation might view this verse as indicative of human free will.
Some people chose to believe in Jesus and His miracles, while others chose to reject and oppose Him.
- A Calvinist might consider this verse an example of the doctrine of predestination, where the differing responses to Jesus' miracle were ordained as part of God's sovereign plan.
- On the other hand, liberation theology might see the reactions as a reflection of the socio-political struggles of the oppressed, with the Pharisees representing the oppressive structures of the time.
Practical Applications
John 11:46 can have several practical applications in daily life:
- It serves as a caution against the danger of groupthink.
Just as some went to the Pharisees, individuals today should be critical in their thinking and not simply follow the crowd.
- This verse also encourages personal reflection upon witnessing or experiencing transformative events, challenging people to consider their own reactions and beliefs.
Cross-References
- John 11:45 – "Then many of the Jews which came to Mary, and had seen the things which Jesus did, believed on him."
- John 12:10-11 – "But the chief priests consulted that they might put Lazarus also to death; Because that by reason of him many of the Jews went away, and believed on Jesus."
- Matthew 12:14 – "Then the Pharisees went out, and held a council against him, how they might destroy him."
Language Study
In the original Greek text:
- "Some of them" translates to "τινες ἐξ αὐτῶν" (tines ex auton), indicating an unspecified number among them.
- "Went their ways" is derived from "ἀπῆλθον" (apēlthon), meaning they departed or proceeded.
- "Told" translates to "ἀπήγγειλαν" (apēngeilan), which means they reported or declared.
- "Pharisees" comes from "Φαρισαίοις" (Pharisaios), which directly references the sect of Jewish religious leaders.
- "What things" is "ἃ" (ha), a relative pronoun referring to the events witnessed.
Cultural and Religious Comparisons
In other ancient religions, individuals who bear witness to divine or miraculous events might be seen as prophets or sacred messengers. In Ancient Greece, for instance, such a person might be compared to a messenger of the gods like Hermes.
In contrast, in Judaism, there was a strong tradition of verifying signs and wonders against the teachings of the Torah.
Scientific Perspectives
Modern science generally does not affirm the possibility of miracles such as raising someone from the dead, as it opposes the understood laws of nature.
Events described in John 11:46 are usually interpreted metaphorically or as a representation of spiritual truths rather than empirical historical events.
Commentaries
Many biblical scholars and commentators have provided insights on John 11:46:
- Matthew Henry's commentary highlights the division that Jesus’ miracles caused and how it led to the plots against Him.
- The MacArthur Study Bible notes how this event fulfills earlier scriptures that the Messiah would perform signs and that He would also be rejected by many.
- The New International Commentary on the New Testament observes the political and religious tensions caused by Jesus’ public ministry and how it led to an increase in opposition from the authorities.