What does Luke 24:21 mean?
Explanation
The verse Luke 24:21 expresses the disappointment and confusion that Jesus' followers felt after his crucifixion.
They had believed Jesus was the Messiah ("he which should have redeemed Israel"), who would liberate Israel from foreign oppression and restore the kingdom to its former glory.
The phrase "to day is the third day since these things were done" refers to the time elapsed since Jesus' crucifixion.
This is significant because Jesus had foretold that he would rise on the third day.
The disciples' words reflect their loss of hope and the harsh reality of their unmet expectations.
Top Rated Luke Books
Historical Context
Luke 24:21 is part of the post-resurrection narrative in the Gospel of Luke, where two of Jesus' disciples are on the road to Emmaus and are joined by the resurrected Jesus, whom they do not recognize.
The historical context of this verse is in first-century Judea under Roman rule.
The Jews were anticipating a political and military savior to deliver them from Roman rule.
The crucifixion of Jesus, instead of appearing to be a fulfillment of messianic prophecy, seemed to dash all hopes of deliverance.
Theological Insights
Christian theology interprets this verse as emphasizing the disciples' misunderstanding of the nature of Jesus' ministry and messiahship. The disciples expected an earthly king, but the Christian understanding is that Jesus' purpose was spiritual redemption.
Moreover, discussions on prophetic fulfillment point to Jesus fulfilling prophecies like the Suffering Servant in Isaiah 53, rather than a political liberation.
Some theologians suggest that the disciples' disappointment was crucial for their understanding and witnessing of the resurrection, transforming their faith and their mission.
Practical Applications
Luke 24:21 can be used to reflect on the nature of hope and expectation in the face of adversity.
Sometimes what appears as failure or the end of one's hopes is a precursor to a new understanding or the unfolding of a different purpose.
Practical applications of this verse include trusting in God's plan even when it seems counter to expectations and understanding that divine timing can conflict with human timing.
Cross-References
- Luke 24:5-7: "...Why seek ye the living among the dead? He is not here, but is risen: remember how he spake unto you when he was yet in Galilee,"
- John 20:9: "For as yet they knew not the scripture, that he must rise again from the dead."
- Psalm 22:1-18: This passage is often associated with the suffering of Christ and reflects the nature of his mission as the Messiah.
- Isaiah 53:3-5: Describes the Suffering Servant, seen as a prophecy of Jesus' atoning sacrifice for humanity's sins.
Language Study
In the original Greek text, the key phrase "which should have redeemed" is translated from "ἤλπιζεν λυτροῦσθαι" (ēlpizen lytrousthai).
The term "ἤλπιζεν" (ēlpizen) is the imperfect tense of "ἐλπίζω" (elpizō), which means "to hope".
It indicates a continuous past action. "λυτροῦσθαι" (lytrousthai) is an infinitive form from "λυτρόω" (lytroō) which means "to release by paying a ransom," commonly used in the context of redemption or salvation.
Cultural and Religious Comparisons
The expectation of a redeemer in Luke 24:21 can be compared with other ancient cultures that had messianic figures.
For instance, in some strands of Zoroastrianism, there was an expectation of a Saoshyant, a savior figure.
In Jewish tradition, the idea of a messianic age is prevalent, where a messiah figure would establish a period of peace and harmony.
The disappointment expressed by the disciples resonates with the universal human experience of disillusionment when a deeply held belief or prophecy appears unfulfilled.
Scientific Perspectives
From a scientific perspective, discussions about Jesus' resurrection and the anticipation of the disciples in Luke 24:21 generally do not intersect with empirical scientific inquiry, as they involve matters of faith and supernatural events.
However, psychology may offer insights into human behavior in relation to hope, belief, and cognitive dissonance experienced by the disciples in the face of unexpected outcomes.
Commentaries
According to renowned biblical scholars, this verse is reflective of the disciple's lack of understanding of Jesus's words about his own death and resurrection.
Matthew Henry's Commentary states that often Jesus Christ's own disciples have more wrong thoughts about the Christ and his kingdom, taking it to be of this world.
Similarly, the Pulpit Commentary elaborates on the concept of the third day being significant in Judaism and the disciple's anticipation of immediate change, which did not align with what actually happened, contributing to their confusion and disappointment.