What does Mark 10:5 mean?
Explanation
Mark 10:5 refers to Jesus responding to the Pharisees' question about whether it is permissible for a man to divorce his wife.
The Pharisees, who were trying to test Jesus, cited Moses' allowance for a man to write a certificate of divorce.
Jesus pointed out that Moses' command was a concession because of the "hardness of heart" of the people.
The verse underscores the idea that the provision was not a reflection of God's ideal for marriage but a pragmatic response to human stubbornness and moral failing.
Instead, Jesus calls his listeners back to the original divine intention for marriage, which is a lifelong union between a man and a woman.
Top Rated Mark Books
Historical Context
In the historical context of 1st-century Judea, divorce was a significant social issue.
Jewish law, based on the teachings of Moses, permitted divorce under certain circumstances.
This was typically enacted by the husband, through a written document known as a "get." The Pharisees, a religious sect at the time, were known for adhering strictly to the law and often sought to test Jesus on these legal points to trap him or find grounds to accuse him.
Theological Insights
From a theological standpoint, there are different interpretations of this verse:
Traditional Christian View: Many Christian theologians see Jesus as affirming the sanctity of marriage, indicating that divorce is not part of God's plan but a result of human sinfulness. 2.
Reformist View: Some theologians see Jesus' response as a radical reform of the existing law, addressing the ease with which men could divorce their wives and emphasizing the importance of women's rights. 3.
Historical-Critical View: Scholars may focus on how Jesus' teachings related to the debates of his time, suggesting he was aligning more with the school of thought that sought to limit divorce rather than with the more permissive interpretations.
Practical Applications
The verse can be applied to modern life in several ways:
Commitment in Marriage: By reflecting on the "hardness of heart," individuals can explore the importance of commitment, patience, compassion, and forgiveness in marriage. 2.
Legal and ethical behavior: In legal disputes or ethical dilemmas, this teaching encourages looking beyond the letter of the law to consider the spirit or the intention behind it. 3.
Personal growth: The verse challenges believers to examine their own "hardness of heart" in various areas and to seek spiritual growth and transformation.
Cross-References
- Matthew 19:8: "He saith unto them, Moses because of the hardness of your hearts suffered you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so."
- Genesis 2:24: "Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh."
- Malachi 2:16: "For the Lord, the God of Israel, saith that he hateth putting away..."
Language Study
"Hardness" in the original Greek is "σκληροκαρδία" (sklerokardia), which conveys a sense of stubbornness or unyielding nature.
"Precept" translates to "ἐντολή" (entolē), meaning a command or ordinance. These key words suggest that the permitting of divorce was an instruction given due to people's inflexibility and moral resistance rather than a desired norm.
Cultural and Religious Comparisons
In comparing to other cultural and religious traditions:
Ancient Greece and Rome also had provisions for divorce, indicating that divorce was not uncommon in the ancient world. 2.
Hinduism and Buddhism have varied views on marriage and divorce, with some interpretations allowing for it under certain circumstances. 3.
In Islam, divorce, known as "talaq," can be initiated by either party, though with some limitations and is seen as a last resort.
Scientific Perspectives
From a modern psychological standpoint, the concept of "hardness of heart" might be likened to emotional rigidity or an unwillingness to empathize and compromise, traits that can lead to marital discord.
Psychological research could provide insights into how such attitudes affect human relationships and the wellbeing of individuals.
Commentaries
Expert opinions on Mark 10:5 include:
William Barclay notes that Jewish law allowed for divorce but that Jesus is emphasizing a return to God's original plan for marriage. 2.
John Calvin writes that Jesus corrected the Pharisees' misinterpretation of the law and pointed them to the love and unity that should define marriage. 3.
R.T.
France comments on how Jesus' teaching respects the Mosaic Law but also points out its role as a temporary concession to human weakness.
These differing perspectives illustrate the ongoing dialogue among biblical scholars and theologians regarding the interpretation of Jesus' teachings on the law, marriage, and human relationships.